Why didn't India develop at the same rate as China? They were both once very powerful civilizations (at various points in their long history), they have smart people, a huge population, and low waged labor, what happened?




Joe Sue

India have smart people? Are you kidding me?

Low waged labor? Idiots are not labors!!!

Do you know India jioned WTO in 1996, 5 years earlier than China.

Do you know India have more railways than China when they are founded.

Pls admit that Indians are lazy, stupid, favor of day dream, good at ostentation only. Does anyone remember PM Modi told Indians they would be SUPER POWER in 2020?

If Africa is a country, it is better than India!

Till today, cows own more rights than human in India!










Questions like these have been answered endlessly.

Please read them.

And please read history.

From fall of the Mughals,

To the British,

And so on.








Marek Cieslik

As India didn't industrialise on as vast a scale as China did.



Sreekrishna Koppuravuri

China has certain advantages. It can take decisions regarding projects quickly. They have financial muscle. They can mobilize labor very quickly. But, this type of development is not at all good. People suffer from pollution. All natural resources would get depleted because of manufacturing and supplying to the whole world. People have to work hard. On the other hand, American development style is good. They invest in industries located at China and reap good profits. Unfortunately, governments create that Chinese type of development is good. Many people also believe in it.



Jamie Cawley

 No one who knows the country will invest in India as - at least until recently - any profit made is simply taken by various government bodies/individuals. That is what keeps India poor.



Dev Gupta, Chief Technology Officer, Semiconductors ( Computer Chips )

Till 1993 the GDP of China and India were comparable, but now China is 4 or 5 times ahead ! What happened ? Outsourcing of manufacturing from the US to China is what happened. Not only was there massive inflow of FDI to China, there was also free flow of US technology, created about 100 million new jobs ( 20 % of total ) in China, on top of that China was allowed to run up a Trade Deficit of $350 billion a year with the US for the last 20 years. So is it any wonder that the Chinese economy has grown 30x in the last 30 years ! Of course we have to acknowledge that the Chinese themselves also worked very hard and smart to make the most of this Bonanza with no parallel in human history. But part of that working hard and smart also included tempting Japanese and German Co.s ( Kawasaki and Siemens ) with promise of buying High Speed Trains and then pirate their technologies. But the lesson has been learned and no one in High Tech trusts China anymore. The US has blocked the Chinese from buying 3 computer chip companies.



Hh Aa

First, China is more united. The Chinese people have a cultural foundation of thousands of years and are not like the cultural foundation of the fault in India.

Second, China has a better electoral system.

Third, China has been honed and prepared for decades in the early stage of reform and opening up. The founding of New China laid the foundation for China.Resume the college entrance examination and start the talent pool. Then reform and opening up allowed China’s economy to take off,

Fifth, China's social atmosphere. The feudal superstition of China a hundred years ago is more serious than the racial system of India. However, the ideological liberation activities of China’s May Fourth Movement, the Cultural Revolution and so on have made China’s feudal superstitions less and less. Now most people believe that science is rejuvenating, and Chinese people know The princes will have a kind of relationship with each other. Although the ethnic system in India has been canceled for decades, it may just be abolished. Most of the thoughts are still deeply rooted in the hearts of the Indian people.

Sixth, the Chinese are more diligent. I went on a business trip to China and India and found the same job. It takes a month for the Chinese to spend only one day doing things. The Indians sat down and prayed after a while, and the Chinese felt that work was a challenge. Everyone works hard for the next challenge.






译文来源:三泰虎  http://www.santaihu.com/49217.html 译者:Joyceliu


Manuj Joshi

The main reason behind this is that China choosed agriculture as its prime moving force after its independence and they use their agricultural gains to sponser their industrial sector and they later on progressed to service sector.

While India chose industrial sector as its prime moving force after its independence, where country's large number of peoples are suffering from poverty, country do not have food security,country have low investment capital to invest in infrastructure sector I don't think moving straightforward to industrial sector is a sound decision. By not choosing agriculture as PMF we didn't gave a chance to our farmers to progress through agriculture and then progress to manufacturing sector as China did.After new economic policy or we can say LPG reforms the country directly jumps to service sector. The country does not go stepwise in progressing. Today agriculture sector accounted for 13.7% of the GDP and have 50% of the workforce in other words 50% of country's population is relying on 13.7% of GDP. I think that is the real reason that we are not developing in the same rate as China.




转载请注明出处!:首页 > 网贴翻译 > 印度 » 为什么印度的发展速度不如中国,两国都曾经是强大文明啊,原因何在?